Skip to main content

Cortisone or Physical Therapy for Knee Osteoarthritis?

good good... let the cortisone flow through you - emperor ...



Arthritis of the knee is a real pain in the butt, but a little bit lower.  It's very common and there is a lot of conflicting evidence out there about what the best treatments are for them.  Some research has shown that nothing works particularly well and others will point to any number of things that do work, including

  • Weight Loss
  • Physical Therapy
  • Braces
  • Turmeric & Glucosamine/Chondroitin
  • Topical OTC pain relievers (Aspercreme, Arnica, Ben Gay)
  • Topical prescription anti-inflammatory medications (diclofenac)
  • NSAID's like ibuprofen or naproxen (more about that here)
  • Cannabis
  • Glucocorticoid (Cortisone is a brand name) injections
  • Hyaluronic Acid Injections (Synvisc is the main one I've heard of)
  • Prolotherapy
  • Stem cell injections
  • Knee surgeries
And there are probably more that I've missed but these are the major ones.  I've had patients who have done all of these - some swear by them, some say they've done nothing at all and some say they worked for a little while and then stopped.  

One limitation of our current medical system is that doctors often have the incentive to perform procedures instead of counseling and so more effective treatments may not be what they go with.  

From what I've seen, weight loss and physical therapy have been the most effective, lowest risk treatments, though they take the longest to work.  The orthopedists I've worked with often quote that every pound you lose takes 4 pounds off of your knees because of the torque they experience.  Physical therapy can teach you to use muscles you may have forgotten you had to take some of the pressure off of the knee as well, thus reducing pain and improving function.  

But Cortisone shots are what people most talk about - it sounds great to say, a lot of athletes do it and oftentimes does work.  But how well does it work?

There was a recent study in the New England Journal of Medicine looking at this which showed that while both physical therapy and glucocorticoid injections improved pain after 9 months, the physical therapy was much more effective.  

Given the risks of glucocorticoid injections (albeit minimal, but there is a remote chance of infection and it does slightly hasten cartilage loss), the more sustainable and apparently more effective answer is knee physical therapy combined with weight loss if you have weight to lose.

If you don't have access to a physical therapist, there are a lot of exercises you can get started with online - here are some I found.

Popular posts from this blog

What is the Best Type of Exercise?

Reader submission: "What is the best type of exercise to get a low heart rate"  The idea being that cardio-respiratory fitness, basically how well your heart and lungs are working, goes along with a lower resting heart rate as we can see marathon runners and sprinters with resting heart rates in the 40's or 50's.  It's also more recently been shown to have some beneficial long term effects on brain volume as people get older, which sounds like a good thing, unless you have a small head.  Fun fact:  For UFC fight clearance, they make us check people's heart rates before and after doing 100 jumps - it doesn't change much from what I've seen. There's a lot of different opinions out there, so instead of doing a lot of reading, I walked into the middle of our cardiology office and just asked the question loudly and the answers I got boiled down to either long-distance running or high-intensity interval training.  I'm assuming that you can also l
Read more

Trick or Treat or Toy

I was looking for something fun and Halloween based and I found this small study . If you've ever wondered how to give out healthier treats effectively on Halloween without getting your house destroyed, this study looked at close to 300 Trick-or-treaters between ages 3 and 14 to see what would happen if they were offered toy treats instead of candy.  It found that children were just as likely to choose toys as candy and there were no gender differences. The implication of this study is that children will not be disappointed by toy treats on Halloween!
Read more

Osteoarthritis Overview

Why did the pirate have a peg leg?  ARRRRRRRthritis! What is osteoarthritis (OA)? Think of your joints as swinging like doors - the joint capsule is like the hinge to make sure that the door swings easily and quietly.  Over time, the hinge wears down due to a combination of the environment, how often it's used, and any extra pressure or injury to the point where the swinging is stiffer, louder, and the door may not shut completely.  The inflammation that occurs in the joint that leads to pain, popping sounds and sensations, and ultimately trouble using the joint, is osteoarthritis (there are some less common forms of arthritis, like rheumatoid arthritis, which is a very different thing, so we'll just talk about osteoarthritis for now). Who gets osteoarthritis? Short answer is everybody.  Under 35, you have less than 0.1% chance of having it.  Over 55, 80% of people have it to some degree.  It's a merit badge you get for living longer and a reminder that the wisdom
Read more